- Johnny-Lee Reinoso
- Posts
- How to Assume the Sale: A Secret Weapon for Cold Callers
How to Assume the Sale: A Secret Weapon for Cold Callers

By Johnny-Lee Reinoso
In B2B sales, hesitation kills. The second you sound unsure, sheepish, or apologetic, you’ve already lost ground. That’s why the best closers in the world have mastered a mindset and a technique called assuming the sale.
But don’t confuse this with high-pressure trickery. Assuming the sale isn’t about bullying your prospect into signing on the dotted line. It’s about leading with authority. It’s about guiding your buyer confidently to the next step — not leaving the decision floating in the air like an awkward first date.
In today’s business climate, with short attention spans, AI clutter, and more digital noise than ever, assuming the sale is your golden ticket. It’s your ticket to booking more meetings, faster closes, higher confidence, and ultimately more bottom-line revenue.
Let’s break this down.
Coming Up: Join JLR’s FREE live masterclass: How to Cold Call The C-Suite to learn the exact cold calling framework that scaled a consulting firm from $10M to $120M in revenue.
Why Most Salespeople Get It Wrong
I’ll never forget the pest-control rep who knocked on my door a while back. He pitched for five minutes, ignored all my signals of disinterest, then shoved a tablet in my hand and said:
“Just sign here, we’ll be out this week.”
Wrong move.
Why? Because he tried to assume the sale without first earning the right to do so. He hadn’t qualified me. He hadn’t gotten a single “yes” out of me. He hadn’t even confirmed if I had the problem his service was designed to solve.
That’s not assumptive selling — that’s desperation. And it stinks.
Here’s the deal: assuming the sale only works when you’ve built trust, uncovered pain points, and positioned yourself as the obvious solution. Skip those steps and you’ll repel prospects faster than a robocall during dinner.
The Power of Assuming the Sale in Cold Calling
So why use it? Because prospects want to be led. They’re bombarded by hundreds of decisions every day. They don’t need another option to think about. Instead, they need clarity, direction, and confidence.
And when you assume the sale the right way, you remove friction. You stop sounding like “just another rep” and start sounding like a trusted advisor who knows what comes next.
It’s the difference between:
“Would you like to move forward with us?”
And…
“Let’s set your kickoff meeting for Monday or Wednesday. Which works best?”
Do you see the shift? In the first, you hand all the power over to the prospect. In the second, you confidently guide them to the natural next step.
That’s the magic of assumptive selling.
How to Assume the Sale (Without Sounding Pushy)
Here are practical ways you can start weaving assumptive closes into your cold calls today:
Offer choices, not yes/no questions “We can deliver by Friday or early next week. Which works better for your team?”
Assume payment is a given “Do you want to handle this by credit card or ACH?”
Frame next steps as logistics, not decisions “Should I send the agreement under your name or the company name?”
Embed urgency into your options “We can get your team onboarded this week or next — when do you want to get started?”
Notice something? In every example, the prospect is subtly walking down a path where the decision has already been made. You’re not asking if they’ll work with you. You’re asking how they’d like to get started.
When to Assume the Sale
Timing matters. You don’t throw an assumptive close at a prospect who’s ice-cold, skeptical, or clearly unqualified. That’s how you get hung up on and lose all trust.
Here’s when assuming the sale is not only safe, but highly effective:
The “yesses” are stacking up → They’re nodding, agreeing, leaning in. That’s momentum. Ride it.
BANT is locked in → Budget, Authority, Need, Timing. If those qualification boxes are checked, it’s green light time.
The energy is warm → They’re sharing intel freely, asking follow-up questions, and already picturing a better future with your solution.
The value is stacked and the pitch is done → You’ve connected the dots between their pain and your solution. At this point, the close is the natural next step… so don’t leave it hanging.
When NOT to Assume the Sale
Equally important: know when to pump the brakes.
No real fit → If your solution doesn’t actually solve their problem, don’t force it. You might win a quick deal, but you’ll lose long-term credibility.
Buyer confidence is low → If they sound uninspired, disengaged, or lukewarm, focus on building excitement first. Then circle back to an assumptive close.
They’re unqualified → No budget, no authority, no timeline? Don’t waste your energy here. Qualify first, then assume later.
The best salespeople aren’t robots blasting the same script at everyone. They’re operators who know when to pull the trigger and when to hold fire.
The Inner Game of Assuming the Sale
Here’s where most reps fail: they try to use assumptive closes with the right words but the wrong energy.
Sales isn’t about scripts. It’s about transferring belief. When you believe in your offer with absolute conviction, it shows up in your voice, your posture, your tonality. And when you deliver your assumptive close from that place, prospects tend to lean in and close.
But if you try to “trick” someone with an assumptive close you don’t believe in, they’ll sniff it out instantly. Confidence isn’t just a technique. It’s an inner state.
So before you assume the sale with your prospect, you need to assume the sale with yourself.
Say it out loud before you dial: “My solution will change lives today. My only job is to help people see it.”
That’s the inner game.
Practical Tips for Cold Callers
Roleplay your assumptive closes daily. Don’t just read about assumptive selling… practice it until it’s muscle memory.
Track your tonality. Record your calls. Do you sound confident, calm, and authoritative? Or nervous and apologetic?
Stack mini-yeses. Warm up the assumptive close by getting agreement along the way. Little yeses make the final yes inevitable.
Keep momentum. Don’t drag out the close with endless details. Assume they’re ready and move them to action.
Detach from outcome. The irony? Assuming the sale works best when you don’t need the sale. Relax. Lead with authority. The deals will follow.
Final Words
Assuming the sale isn’t about arrogance. It’s about leadership. It’s about stepping into the trusted advisor role your prospect actually wants you to play.
And these days, when everyone else is relying on AI spam, timid pitches, or hiding behind endless emails, assuming the sale is your unfair advantage.
So the next time you pick up the phone, stop asking permission like a rookie. And start leading like a pro.
Because here’s the truth: the sale is already yours — if you have the guts to assume it.
Until next time… Johnny-Lee Reinoso